I’ve got a pair of Muck Edgewaters that have held up well so far (2 seasons). While the Edgewater doesn’t have as much of a substantial footbed as some of the other models, I feel like it does allow for a little more sensitivity and a softer footfall when ground hunting (which is all I do).
I can’t imagine winter without my Schnee’s packboots. They’re hands down the best, and I live in them from Nov. to April. But I don’t think I’d use the ADV sole for doing much groundhunting – too stiff and heavy. Unfortunately, more and more of their models seem to only be offered with the ADV. One of these days I’ll order a pair of Schnee’s with the old school tread sole.
