Home Forums Bows and Equipment 40 # recurve and Ultra-EFOC arrow search

Viewing 19 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • tom-wisconsin
      Member
        Post count: 240

        I had high hopes today but things did not work out. I have about 18 GT expedition arrows, 30″ and 7.4 gpi with .500 spine. I had hopes of using these arrows for hunting with UEFOC and sufficient wt. They were too stiff as shown by bare shaft tuning. I am left handed. The nock end veered left during arrow flight. The shaft alone ways 222 gr. I put 9 gr nocks and bare shafts. I had a 14.6 grams insert witch I put wts screwed into the back of the insert. Plus I used 300 gr field tips. So even with 504.6 grains up front they were still too stiff. My bare shaft tuning consisted of watching the arrow flight. Maybe I am wrong but These arrows kicked left which for us lefties is too stiff. HAS ANYONE ANY IDEAS

        Tom

      • Stephen Graf
        Moderator
          Post count: 2429

          How much left?

          One of the good characteristics of extreme front of center arrows is that they correct very quickly. If your bare arrow is not acting too crazy, I would fletch one up and shoot it. You may find that it flies just great.

          I’m a little confused by your description of spine. The arrows are gold tips right? Gold Tip measures their spine by poundage range like 55-75. Beaman measures their spine in inches of deflection like .500. Are they beaman’s or gold tips?

          My gut tells me a 700+ grain arrow just won’t do well out of a 40 lb bow no matter what you do. Mostly because the bow will take so long to relax, giving you a lot of time after release to adversely affect the arrow’s flight. Just a guess.

        • Ed Zachary
            Post count: 58

            GoldTip does list their deflection and bow weight range. Crunching the numbers, your shafts have an equivalent static spine of 63 pounds. I’d treat that as a reference point and not much more.

            You don’t mention your draw length, I’m assuming it’s around 29″, with a 30″ BOP?

            Call me loony, but I’m suspecting with 500+ grains up front, you may actually be showing a weak spine condition…..a dreaded false-positve.

            Two things to try –
            1.) Make a large decrease (100 grain or so) in your point weight, just to see what happens.

            2.) Test 3 fletched and 3 bare at 15 & 20 yards and their relative impacts to confirm
            your findings. Use your fletched arrows as a reference.

            Sometimes chasing nock left/right is fruitless.

            Good luck, let us know what your testing shows,
            I’m curious as to what you will find.

          • tom-wisconsin
            Member
            Member
              Post count: 240

              Steve Graf wrote: How much left?

              I’m a little confused by your description of spine. The arrows are gold tips right? Gold Tip measures their spine by poundage range like 55-75. Beaman measures their spine in inches of deflection like .500. Are they beaman’s or gold tips?

              My gut tells me a 700+ grain arrow just won’t do well out of a 40 lb bow no matter what you do. Mostly because the bow will take so long to relax, giving you a lot of time after release to adversely affect the arrow’s flight. Just a guess.

              Thanks very much for your input, Steve.

              They are Gold Tip 3555 Expedition Hunters. According to the Gold Tip web site the followings specs are listed.
              3555 Black 7.4gpi .500″ spine 30″ length

            • tom-wisconsin
              Member
              Member
                Post count: 240

                Ed Zachary wrote:
                You don’t mention your draw length, I’m assuming it’s around 29″, with a 30″ BOP?

                Thanks for your help Ed.

                My draw length for a compound bow was determined to be 29 inches. Ed I do not know what BOP is.

                I appreciate your ideas I will try them this afternoon.

              • Ed Zachary
                  Post count: 58

                  Tom wrote: “My draw length for a compound bow was determined to be 29 inches. Ed I do not know what BOP is.”

                  Sorry, I should have said a 30″ arrow….which is 30″ from bottom of arrow nock groove to the back of the point (B.O.P.).

                  Your draw length may be the same as with your compound, maybe not. The upshot is, what is your poundage, at your draw length with this bow?

                • tom-wisconsin
                  Member
                  Member
                    Post count: 240

                    My poundage is 40 lbs. I took the bow to my pro shop and they put it on the scale at 29 inches. I was reading 2008 Ashby study update report. He has a GT ultra 3555 arrow with 415 tip wt which tuned correctly. I am going to set up my arrows the same. I have 30″ BOP. I think he said he has 27 ” BOP arrows. I’ll let you know how it goes. I am trying to produce a ultra FOC arrows.

                    Thanks for your help

                    Tom.

                  • sapcut
                      Post count: 159

                      I have set up some arrows for my wife shooting 40 lbs. They are GT Ultralight Entrada 500. 6.3 gpi

                      620ish grains (don’t remember off hand)
                      29″ from nock groove to cut carbon.
                      100 gr. brass insert
                      300 gr. field point
                      20 gr. 2117 footing
                      32% FOC measuring from nock to cut carbon
                      Flys great.
                      AND….I can actually add more weight before they get too weak.

                      It should work for you.

                    • tom-wisconsin
                      Member
                      Member
                        Post count: 240

                        Thanks Sapcut

                        I wonder if the gpi is the key. The GT expedition hunters I am trying to use are 7.4 gpi I understand the spine is the same. I will go check my bow wt again at the pro shop. I know my Predator II 20/40 .600 arrows with a 145 field tip bare shafted slightly weak. But I put on 5″ feathers and they flew great. Now that is 420 up front with your wife’s arrows.

                        Sapcut did you bare shaft tune them?

                      • sapcut
                          Post count: 159

                          Yes, at least when trying to get Ultra EFOC, the lightest gpi but stiffest is the key. But the 7.4 gpi arrows should also work well.
                          Just weighed them again and they are 614 gr. 420 gr. up front and 33.6% FOC.
                          I usually bareshaft them a tiny bit weak and fletch. Then they are perfect with 4″ nanner feathers.
                          I am more interested in how they fly with the feathers on than off.

                        • tom-wisconsin
                          Member
                          Member
                            Post count: 240

                            Thanks Sapcut. I just was rereading the bare shaft tuning article on the ACS site. It says ignore what the bareshafts look like in flight. Just see how they group with the arrows with feathers. Maybe that’s my problem I was looking at the arrow kicking nock left in flight. Bare in mind I shoot lefty. I will follow the instructions. If your spouses arrows work and the ones Dr. Asby work with about 415-420 up front I should be fine.

                            Thanks I will keep everyone posted.

                          • tom-wisconsin
                            Member
                            Member
                              Post count: 240

                              I did set up arrows with 430 tip wt. They flew straight after I took off my beaver balls string silencers and the rubber mushrooms. They flew straight most of the time accept when I did not have good form and release. Then they acted stiff spine. Because I am a beginner the fact that Sapcut and his better half 😀 already did the work for me, was a big help. When my form becomes more consistent I will be able to fine tune my set up.

                              I feel we should have threads set up for each bow wt with info on what arrow set up works for each as a general starting point. So if you have a 50# bow filling in a form on the thread with all the necessary info for the experienced archers on this site would be very helpful and we can then easily monitor how someones set up worked when they make a kill. This may be a good way to increase the data that Dr. ED needs. Just my two cents as a newbie.

                            • tom-wisconsin
                              Member
                              Member
                                Post count: 240

                                Indian Archery Recurve 1965 40# at my DL.

                                Gold Tip Expedition Hunters 3555
                                7.4 gpi
                                657 gr. overall wt.
                                30 7/16 inch arrows from nock groove to cut carbon
                                125 gr. Insert (15 grain insert plus 110 gr PDP wts.)
                                300 grain field point
                                31.93 % FOC

                                When I have good form they fly straight bare shafted from 15 yards. 😀
                                For hunting just need to use 100 gr brass inserts, 125 gr BH adapter and a 200 grain BH to have the same FOC and WT.
                                :D:D:D:D:D

                              • katman
                                  Post count: 7

                                  Tom, you will need to check broadhead flight with fletched since you are changing location of the weight, more head weight(325 vs 300) and less in the shaft(100 vs 125), my guess is you will weaken the spine some by moving more weight to the end of the shaft vs inside, that’s been my experience. But since you may be a tad strong that should help.

                                • sapcut
                                    Post count: 159

                                    Katman and Tom,
                                    That is exactly correct. The less weight inside the shaft (which gets the weight farther AWAY from the balance point) the weaker the spine will be AND the higher the FOC will be. But like Katman said, if your arrows are a tad stiff then you should be fine. You just need to fletch them how ya like’em and shoot with broadheads to find out what adjustments you need.

                                  • tom-wisconsin
                                    Member
                                    Member
                                      Post count: 240

                                      Thanks Katman and Sapcut. I still need to buy my broadheads and adapters. I will keep you informed. I really appreciate everyones help.

                                      Tom

                                    • tom-wisconsin
                                      Member
                                      Member
                                        Post count: 240

                                        FYI
                                        I took three 300 gr field tips and wrapped masking tape around them until they weighed 325 gr each. Then used them with the 100 gr brass inserts. They were still too stiff but I adjusted my brace ht down and this did the job. Brace ht is now 6 7/8 inches and arrow nock is 7/16 inches above center.

                                        This allowed me to have the wt up front on the field tips. Yes I weighed the field tips after I shot. They still weight the same. I guess I waisted my money on the wpt weight system. :D. I am going to go with 200 gr grizzlies or Abowyer broad heads.

                                      • tom-wisconsin
                                        Member
                                        Member
                                          Post count: 240

                                          Found out what was happening that was preventing me from making this work.:oops:

                                          The brace ht was way off. I had it set way too low which affected my arrow flight. I started with the brace ht at about 6 7/8 from string to deepest point of bow grip. I started by twisting the string three turns to increase the brace height. Then shooting four bare shaft arrows.

                                          Gold Tip Expedition Hunters 3555, spine 0.500, 7.4 gpi, 30″ arrows with 100 gr brass inserts and 300 gr field points. No fletching, just bare shafts.

                                          As I progressed the arrow flight improved until now at 7.5 in brace ht the arrows are no longer kicking left. They are starting to fly straight. As I continued to increase the brace ht some of the arrows started kicking nock right which for this lefty indicates a weak arrow. I had to stop the brace ht adjusting as I had to go to work. I am not completely stable with good form so I will have to take that into consideration. But I am really excited that I found out what I was doing wrong. Probably would have saved a lot of time if I had a good traditional coach.

                                          I appreciate all the help I am getting from all of you and I hope this is helping other newbies by following my mistakes.:D

                                          Tom

                                        • mswickard
                                            Post count: 34

                                            Fletch some arrows up and see how they work then compare to your bare shafts. Sounds like you got her figured out.

                                            Mike

                                          • tom-wisconsin
                                            Member
                                            Member
                                              Post count: 240

                                              I am finished. My brace ht is 8 1/8 and arrow nock is 1/2 above level. It would have been easier if I had known the brace ht range of the bow. But they are flying straight now. I am set for sure. Thanks for all your help everyone.

                                          Viewing 19 reply threads
                                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.