I have always used fletch-tite on carbon and aluminum and duco on wood with laquer or urethane finishes. For nocks I use the same glue I used for the fletch for each type of arrow. Never had any problems and I’m not very fastidious when it comes to cleaning shafts before fletching. I have tried the bearpaw tape with mixed results. There is definitely a shelf life with the tape.
Used super glue for other tasks but does not seem like my first choice for fletch.