Home › Forums › Campfire Forum › German storks, African arrows
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
I stumbled across an interesting confluence of traditional archery and human understanding of the world. This story comes from the German town of Klutz, circa 1822. Apparently the disappearance of birds during winter was quite a mystery to our recent ancestors, with scholarly essays of the day suggesting many birds hibernate during winter. Even that great and flawed philosopher of antiquity Aristotle reckoned swallows, storks and kites hibernated in the winter.
Well, in Klutz in 1822 a rather interesting thing happened. A stork flew into town, run through with a central African arrow. This little piece of evidence led to the understanding that the birds go somewhere else for the winter. Isn’t that an astounding thing?
Things like that always make me wonder about what astoundingly obvious things we don’t know about right now that future generations will laugh at us for, we silly ancestors of yesteryear 😀
Anyway, that first stork was such a marvel it was stuffed and preserved and still lives in a German university. Here’s a picture:
If you want to know more google Rostocker Pfeilstorch.
Jim
-
Jim that is very interesting!
I also wonder what things we think are best, right, safe, etc that future generations will laugh at us for.
My wife thinks in 50 years you will see commercials on tv about plastics exposure just like the asbestos commercials we see now.
Thanks for sharing.
-
Jim,
I once saw a documentary on birds that featured the Stork. It showed how the males left Africa first and arrived before the females to get the nest cleaned up for the season.
I cannot imagine making that flight with that arrow stuck up my a#$ though.
-
Wow, Jim, that’s truly fascinating. (I had lots of time to read when I was in the military too, while others were shooting pool or playing Ping-Pong.)
First, I wonder if the town name Klutz has anything to do with the origin of that slang term for a clumsy person?
Second and more interesting, I am guessing that’s an atlatl dart/spear, not an arrow. First there’s no fletching. And even if we overlook the length, the diameter and overall mass seem too great for an arrow. Nor do I see a string notch, though it could be there. But arrow or dart, it does demonstrate some feature that harken back to the Paleolithic, or old stone age, namely the detachable foreshaft, so that the shaft can be retrieved from an animal and quickly fitted with a new foreshaft (to which the broadhead is fitted), saving labor in making a new shaft, the need to carry multiple complete darts or spears, and allowing for “speed loading” during an active hunt. Second, the broadhead appears to be stone and of a shape amazingly similar to heads an anthropologist friend (and fellow trad bowhunter) is digging up in Ethiopia, dating to the Mesolithic (middle stone age), some 40,000 years ago. He thinks they could be arrowheads, as they’re too small (smaller than this one) to be dart points. Maybe …
Finally … poor damn bird. I hate it when we don’t get it right.
-
Dave, you may well be right about it in fact being a spear. I read a German article that referred to a ‘Speer’ (spear) that had been carried by the first ‘pfeilstorch’ (arrow stork).
Yeah, it looks like the result of a speculative shot at best doesn’t it? I shot a duck with archery tackle and when I was eating it found a quite a lot of metal shot inside her. No one would have ever known that she had been wounded by a shotgun. If my arrow had speared her and she’d gotten away, photos of her would no doubt be used as evidence of the unnecessary cruelty of bowhunting. A bowhunter’s shame is out there for all to see.
Jim
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.