Home Forums Campfire Forum Private land (more ethics)

Viewing 9 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • gigglemonk
        Post count: 146

        I teach yoga classes a few days a week and some of the people that attend are curious about hunting but have less experience than me. Last night a client and I had talk after class.

        He is a kyudo practitioner (zen archery) and wants me to take him spotting for deer one of these days. Turns out he has access to a 300 acre ranch in the nearby foothills. Today he and I went up there and met the landowner. Surprisingly, she gave me written permission to hunt on the ranch year round.

        I explained the seasons here in ca and what zone the ranch falls in. When I told them that deer hunting is only allowed a few months out of the year, they both stated that they thought because its private property the deer can be hunted year round. When I told them that is not how it works they kept going.

        Again, I was surprised, here are two individuals that have never hunted, rarely eat meat and can easily be mislabeled as anti hunting, trying to convince me that I can hunt anytime I like on private property.

        I explained how that would be poaching, the reasoning behind seasons and zones,etc. it kept going though. The kicker was when one of asked if it’d be easy to get caught. I answered them honestly, that getting caught would be extremely unlikely, but getting away with something doesn’t justify it.

        This interaction made all the more clear to me that hunter education is just as important for nonhunters.

        Ok, what else should’ve been done or said?

      • lyagooshka
          Post count: 600

          I think “actions speak louder than words” applies really well here. If they do not hunt, then they are not taking animals out of season. So it’s really up to you to do the right thing. Just keep doing it and they will see what the difference between hunters and poachers is. Then, when the anti’s try to paint us all with a broad brush, they will tell their friends “that’s just not the way true hunters are”. Be well.

          Alex

          😀

        • jmsmithy
          Member
            Post count: 300

            lyagooshka wrote: I think “actions speak louder than words” applies really well here. If they do not hunt, then they are not taking animals out of season. So it’s really up to you to do the right thing. Just keep doing it and they will see what the difference between hunters and poachers is. Then, when the anti’s try to paint us all with a broad brush, they will tell their friends “that’s just not the way true hunters are”. Be well.

            Alex

            😀

            Couldn’t agree more Alex….in this case it’s all about how we, the hunters, conduct ourselves among those who do not know / not informed / (don’t care??). It’s incumbent on us to be the standard bearers and hopefully our actions will educate those that aren’t informed. The killer is for all the good we do, it only takes one dumb SOB to undo a lot of goodwill 👿

            We need to do everything we can to counteract these idiots every chance we get….>>>–>

          • skifrk
              Post count: 387

              I like the lead by example, you might want to try and find some hunting literature that explains the difference between poaching and hunting to share with them.

            • Mark Turton
                Post count: 759

                Strictly speaking I think hunting out of season would be illegal but as you have permission would not be poaching.

                Good luck with your conversion of the non hunters, as folks that rarely eat meat they may well enjoy some venison with all the benefits over farmed meats.

                Just reread your post and you highlight that they are non-hunters and not anti-hunting (otherwise you would not have got permission, bit slow today) the world over these are the folks we need to be educating, does anyone have literature aimed specifically at this group?

                Mark.

              • Rogue
                  Post count: 84

                  I have several clients that feel the same way as the people you describe, Not being big meat eaters they seem to think that the deer are competition. I have even helped build fences around gardens to keep the deer out.

                  I don’t think that I can say it any better than the above posts, that actions speak louder than words.

                  Good luck

                  Bill

                • gigglemonk
                    Post count: 146

                    Thanks all. looks like Ill be hunting up there during the late season.

                    I think they understand the restrictions around hunting a bit more now. Either that or they are starting to realize how serious killing a deer really is. After an explanation of what happens when the vitals are hit in a perfect situation I think they understood the gravity of a thoughtful hunt.

                  • William Warren
                    Member
                      Post count: 1384

                      They sound like some folks I used have permission from. They just wanted the deer gone and did not care how many I killed. I told them I would not shoot over the limit allowed. I hunted it one season and I was not successful enough to suit them so we parted ways. Hope that does not happen to you.

                      If deer are eating their crops or other resources does CA have depredation permitting to thin a deer herd? Can the landowner get permits to thin the herd legally? If so, it could afford you more shot opportunities on that property and maybe more meat in the freezer.

                    • Murray
                      Member
                        Post count: 46

                        Years ago I met a lady land-owner, who gave me permission to deer hunt. She encouraged me to come and kill deer at night, because they were in her garden. She DID NOT have any kind of legal status to allow this, but she really tried to talk me into night shooting. Later, I asked about shooting some doves on her place, and she got all excited, and said “No, I don’t allow any dove shooting. Doves are mentioned in the Bible!” This was (is) fairly common across much of the South.

                        On opening day of deer season, it became apparent that she stopped people on the road to give them hunting permission.Her yard looked like a parking lot. We stayed til daylight, ducking centerfire rifle shots that folks were throwing at flying duck, then low crawled to the vehicle and got out of there. Going down the road, one of our crew remembered a friend who had property, so we stopped by, got permission, and have been hunting there since 1972. We’ve become great friends with the family.

                      • gigglemonk
                          Post count: 146

                          This situation has nothing to do with the landowner wanting the deer to be shot. It has do with the landowner not knowing the seasons and her not wanting the gov’t to restrict what can be done on her land.

                          There are no complaints about the deer. She seems to be of the mindset that if its her land she can do whatever she pleases.

                          With that in mind, I don’t think depredation tags are the way to go. I think that educating her on game laws and deer biology would be more appropriate.

                      Viewing 9 reply threads
                      • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.